I happen to be reading Someplace Safe with Somebody Good by Jan Karon. I have been rereading the entire series in anticipation of this latest release, so I feel like an expert on Father Tim and Cynthia Kavanagh. Since this is my "Dream" Cast, I'm assuming that there are no limitations (like that they are still living) on who I can pick.
James Garner would have been perfect for the role of Father Tim and Helen Mirren is the picture of Cynthia in my head.
Fun question to ponder, Shannon. But now I'm slightly disappointed that I'll never see this couple on the Silver Screen.